Access to records will reduce patient stress and anxiety

Laura Fulcher

Patient assurance committee representative Date: 29 November 2018

Our patient representative Laura Fulcher explains how poor access to records leaves people feeling powerless, and how she hopes to see patients put at the centre of digital change in care.

“Dealing with the NHS is a full-time job for you, isn’t it?” asked my GP one day, during yet another appointment of trying to wrestle details of my health record out of the system.

I had a simple request: I needed information on how often I should be screened for my Lynch Syndrome diagnosis, a genetic condition that increases cancer risk. This information was crucial to me – I needed to feel confident that my condition was being monitored, secure in the knowledge that I didn’t need to chase scans or appointments.

Sadly, my GP did not have access to this information herself and given it had not been shared with my hospital team also, as I feared, no provider could take responsibility for my screening.

“Shall I write to the genetic team to query it?” she asked.

I foresaw the months this would take – for the GP to dictate the letter, the secretary to type it up to be sent to the hospital thirty miles up the road, only for the same process to be repeated again when the information was relayed back. And the chasing I would need to do to get it all completed – because these things always get a little lost along the way.

The burden of it all felt too much. It was a burden that weighed heavily on my shoulders since my diagnosis with bowel cancer four years earlier.

Lack of information and the consequent powerlessness were recurrent themes during the fifteen months I had to wait for my cancer diagnosis. I was very much lost in the system with no access to information that might empower me to raise concerns and to take greater responsibility for my health. Had I known how long I would need to wait for appointments, had I access to my GP notes so that I knew when to return if symptoms didn’t clear up, had I known that no information was being relayed from out of hours doctors, and had I known my attendance at A&E had not been recorded appropriately, I would have raised these as issues. Instead, I trusted in the NHS believing that someone was ultimately responsible for my care.

Yet fundamentally, the only person who can be responsible is the individual themselves and you cannot look after yourself without access to your own medical information.

Instead, I felt like a small child again, vulnerable and helpless. I’d have loved to see referral letters and communication between providers, knowing where I was in the system, where I was headed, and perhaps how long I must wait. I needed a helping hand – information on who was responsible for which aspect of my health and how to contact them – both by phone and email.

It’s not just lack of access to information that cause issues, but the content of the medical record themselves. In its current state, information focuses on diagnosis and treatments, with no room for details that are important to me – the consequences of these treatments and the long-term effects they have on my life. It is dealing with these consequences that is now the priority in my eyes. What an improvement it would make if people were able to contribute to their own record, restoring some of the eroded autonomy that ill health causes.

And it’s about validation too. When patients self-report issues, it often goes overlooked when not supported by a clinician. During my own long wait for diagnosis, when I relayed information from the out of hours doctor and the need for further tests, the GP did not take me seriously due to the absence of a clinician’s report. Since then, often clinicians do not believe me when I tell them of my bowel cancer diagnosis; ‘you’re much too young,’ they say. Wouldn’t it be wonderful for health records to be created collaboratively, changing the ethos of healthcare: patients *can* contribute usefully, their lived experience validated.

In the meantime, all this lack of empowerment breeds anxiety. It is no wonder to me that there’s a relationship between physical health issues and consequent psychological problems given how little autonomy people have. As a usually independent person, it is stressful knowing that I do not have access to information to champion myself. And while the NHS focuses on ‘care’, all I can say is, what use is better care if I am made to feel all the more powerless and vulnerable? Truly, what I need is confidence and control over my medical information helping me to lead a better, brighter, independent life.

I joined the PRSB in September as a citizen representative on the Assurance Committee and provide feedback on all kinds of exciting documents, applications, and consultation proposals from across the digital sphere, ensuring that public voice is heard. Current aims are to try to make data papers a little less jargon-tastic (so that they actually make sense to most people!); learning what other patient involvement mechanisms exist in data decisions so that public reps can work together; and supporting the PRSB in their aim to put the patient at the centre of digital strategy that seems so very distant from front-line health care.

Sign up to our newsletter

We use an an email marketing service called Mailchimp, to deliver our newsletters. You can unsubscribe at any time using links in the emails you receive.

PRSB on Twitter

[ap-twitter-feed-pro]

Personalised care and support planning for people with severe mental illness

A review of a sample of current care plans, and the way they have been developed, may be helpful in identifying the priorities for this improvement. The PRSB Implementation Guide provides more detailed explanations about each element of the plan, including advice on how the planning process might be best conducted.
These questions might form a checklist for current plans to be compared with. 

1. Does the plan include an About Me section in which the service user, in their own words, can indicate the information they want to be available about their lives, their values, their interests, and priorities, available for all those who may care for them?
2. Is the approach to developing a care plan patient centred and engaging, allowing plans to be based on patient priorities goals, and aspirations, along with the actions they plan to take and the support that they will receive?
3. Is there space for a “formulation” to be recorded in which the person receiving care and the professionals who provide it, share and record the personal meaning and the origins of the person’s difficulties?
4. Are relevant procedures and therapies recorded?
5. Where relevant, are one or more contingency plans included for anticipatable disruptions, exacerbations, or deterioration, and do they include advice on what to do and points of contact for those called upon to respond?
6. Where relevant are additional supporting plans incorporated, (an example being an “educational and health plan” for someone with a neurodevelopment disorder)
7. Is a version of the plan available to a service user (if they wish to have it) in a form and format that they can understand and find to be of value?
8. How is a version of the plan available to the GP and other key parts of the health and care system?

Work conducted by PRSB and partners recently has looked specifically at the suitability of this approach to the development and documentation of care and support plans for people with Severe Mental Illness. This resulted in an updated version of the standard (v1.4), for use by any service and for any group of service users, but with some modifications to ensure that it meets the needs of this community. The approach to a patient centred process of identifying goals, hopes, and values, and the support needed to achieve them, is fully compatible with and can be conducted using, specific tools in use in mental health, such as DIALOG, DIALOG+, and ReQoL, for example. 

Where analysis indicates the need for improvement in the content and process of personalised care and support planning for patients with Severe Mental Illness, specific improvement projects should be instituted to co-design with service users and their representatives, and the relevant staff groups, new approaches, and documentation that would be of value in delivering improvement. The toolkit includes a range of existing resources that could be used to engage in this improvement work, including signposting to relevant existing approaches informed by patient experience-based design.

Moving to a single holistic plan

A review of a sample of current care plans, and the way they have been developed, may be helpful in identifying the priorities for this improvement. The PRSB Implementation Guide provides A key development, consistent with national policy on support for Personalised Care across all health and care sectors, is the move towards an individual with complex needs having a single, integrated, care plan, rather than a series of plans developed by different parts of the health and social care system in isolation of one another. For a patient with severe mental illness, the related concerns and challenges might form a very prominent part of such an integrated plan; many will also have concurrent health challenges and needs. The intention is that the relevant services work together to plan and wrap support around the patient and their family in an integrated way, rather than as a series of sequential or disconnected encounters in which the service user or their friends and family have to adopt the role of the integrator.

A starting point would be to agree priority groups of service users who may already have more than one care plan because they need care from more than one part of the system of health and social care. This could be initiated by looking at service users registered with some sentinel practices or PCNs. Alternatively, the approach might focus initially on people with defined co-morbidity or risk that entails collaborative care with agencies beyond specialist mental health services.

The focus here is on the process of care planning and agreement on what should be shared, rather than solely on the technology used;

1. What is the process to agree which professional will initiate care planning and act as the “lead point of contact” for the service user?
2. Will initial plans be agreed with the service user in joint consultations or sequentially? Where and how will they be conducted?
3. What will be the process to agree the elements of the plans which should be available to professionals and potential authorised users beyond the immediate care teams, (A&E services, Ambulance Services, Social services, etc.) with the service user’s consent?
4. How will elements of the plan be updated following consultations in a way which is proportionate, to allow contact and progress notes to be maintained by the service conducting the consultation, whilst avoiding unnecessary work for partners in care if there is no significant change to the personalised care and support plan?
5. What are the implications for workload, logistics, and administration arising out of these decisions?

The answers to these questions and others will best be elicited through focused joint working, grounded in real, or at least realistic examples. This will entail process mapping, and co-design with a range of professionals, service users, and families. Resources from the toolkit and outputs from the Simulation element of this project will be valuable. Some organisations would adopt an approach such as a Rapid Process Improvement Workshop, planned over several weeks and conducted over a number of sequential days, to develop prototype ways of working that could be tested in the field.

“If someone’s been working for a period of time, in a form of therapy, for instance, where there’s an agreed plan for the locality when they may present in an emergency situation … then it’s really important for us to be able to see that that information and be able to act appropriately according to that because, you know, there isn’t and there shouldn’t be a stock response to that. These plans are designed to be individualised and personalised.  All services should be giving that personalised approach to care wherever possible. And a standard such as [PCSP standard] definitely moves us closer towards being able to do that. [Not acting on agreed plans] is a key finding in terms of emergency responses over the years where responses have been inappropriate.” – Mental Health Nurse

“Following a particular plan that’s been put into place will result in much better outcomes and prevent the sort of poor outcome which would otherwise be leading to an unplanned hospital admission.” – General Practitioner