Patient view: Why we need safe and secure apps in healthcare

Emma Robertson is the patient lead on our new work to accredit apps and digital health technologies. She speaks to PRSB about why she got involved with the work and the benefits and challenges of using apps to support health and care.

Why did you decide to get involved with the PRSB’s assurance app project?

In 2013 I was diagnosed with breast cancer and in 2015, it became metastatic. I am now in treatment for life, which means I have had a huge amount of experience with health and care services over the years. My treatment has been up and down, and I am in and out of hospital frequently. I want to use my experience to make positive changes in the health and care system. For example, I’ve previously campaigned for pharmaceutical companies to lower drug prices so that they are more affordable for the NHS. I wanted to get involved in the PRSB’s project so that I could use my experience as a patient to support better enhancements in future care.

What is most important to you about developing the accreditation framework for apps?

The most important thing will be safeguarding patients. We want to enable people to make the best possible choices about the apps they are using so they can feel confident in the decisions they are making. It will support people to get more involved in their own health and care and take control, which is really important. Being unwell is a challenging time and many things are out of your control. Apps can help patients to feel like they have more control, as well as providing advice and support.

What type of assurances do you think patients want to feel confident that an app can be trusted?

Trust is a big topic for many people. You are not only trusting an app with your data, you are also trusting that app to provide you with the right answers. You want to know at the very least that it won’t cause you harm, and that hopefully it will benefit you and provide the right support you’re looking for. For an app that patients use before they see a doctor or pharmacist, the main thing will be understanding exactly what is meant by pre-primary care and what the app can provide.

What are you biggest concerns about apps?

I think GDPR is a concern for many people. While there are people who are willing to share their data, others have big concerns about how it could be used and whether it will be used in their way. Some people are so private, they would not want their data to be used even for research purposes. We also have to consider how cost effective they will be for the NHS and user, and how accessible. For example, not everyone has a smart phone or is willing/able to use apps and websites. If there is huge reliance on apps, it could alienate some people.

What kind of apps would you like to see being developed in future?

I have used fitness apps before, but found they are not well tailored to my condition. In future I would like to see more apps that are relevant to certain conditions, as well as apps that can take these into account. For example, could there be a health monitor app specifically for someone living with cancer? Of course, as apps become more developed we will be able to input more information and tailor them to our needs.

How have you found involvement with PRSB to date? would you recommend it to other patients?

I like the fact that PRSB incorporated patient views and has a patient lead on projects. I think it’s incredibly important that our voices are represented, particularly as health and care continues to change and we get more involved. I am really interested in the future of apps and to see how they will impact the future of health and care.

Personalised care and support planning for people with severe mental illness

A review of a sample of current care plans, and the way they have been developed, may be helpful in identifying the priorities for this improvement. The PRSB Implementation Guide provides more detailed explanations about each element of the plan, including advice on how the planning process might be best conducted.
These questions might form a checklist for current plans to be compared with. 

1. Does the plan include an About Me section in which the service user, in their own words, can indicate the information they want to be available about their lives, their values, their interests, and priorities, available for all those who may care for them?
2. Is the approach to developing a care plan patient centred and engaging, allowing plans to be based on patient priorities goals, and aspirations, along with the actions they plan to take and the support that they will receive?
3. Is there space for a “formulation” to be recorded in which the person receiving care and the professionals who provide it, share and record the personal meaning and the origins of the person’s difficulties?
4. Are relevant procedures and therapies recorded?
5. Where relevant, are one or more contingency plans included for anticipatable disruptions, exacerbations, or deterioration, and do they include advice on what to do and points of contact for those called upon to respond?
6. Where relevant are additional supporting plans incorporated, (an example being an “educational and health plan” for someone with a neurodevelopment disorder)
7. Is a version of the plan available to a service user (if they wish to have it) in a form and format that they can understand and find to be of value?
8. How is a version of the plan available to the GP and other key parts of the health and care system?

Work conducted by PRSB and partners recently has looked specifically at the suitability of this approach to the development and documentation of care and support plans for people with Severe Mental Illness. This resulted in an updated version of the standard (v1.4), for use by any service and for any group of service users, but with some modifications to ensure that it meets the needs of this community. The approach to a patient centred process of identifying goals, hopes, and values, and the support needed to achieve them, is fully compatible with and can be conducted using, specific tools in use in mental health, such as DIALOG, DIALOG+, and ReQoL, for example. 

Where analysis indicates the need for improvement in the content and process of personalised care and support planning for patients with Severe Mental Illness, specific improvement projects should be instituted to co-design with service users and their representatives, and the relevant staff groups, new approaches, and documentation that would be of value in delivering improvement. The toolkit includes a range of existing resources that could be used to engage in this improvement work, including signposting to relevant existing approaches informed by patient experience-based design.

Moving to a single holistic plan

A review of a sample of current care plans, and the way they have been developed, may be helpful in identifying the priorities for this improvement. The PRSB Implementation Guide provides A key development, consistent with national policy on support for Personalised Care across all health and care sectors, is the move towards an individual with complex needs having a single, integrated, care plan, rather than a series of plans developed by different parts of the health and social care system in isolation of one another. For a patient with severe mental illness, the related concerns and challenges might form a very prominent part of such an integrated plan; many will also have concurrent health challenges and needs. The intention is that the relevant services work together to plan and wrap support around the patient and their family in an integrated way, rather than as a series of sequential or disconnected encounters in which the service user or their friends and family have to adopt the role of the integrator.

A starting point would be to agree priority groups of service users who may already have more than one care plan because they need care from more than one part of the system of health and social care. This could be initiated by looking at service users registered with some sentinel practices or PCNs. Alternatively, the approach might focus initially on people with defined co-morbidity or risk that entails collaborative care with agencies beyond specialist mental health services.

The focus here is on the process of care planning and agreement on what should be shared, rather than solely on the technology used;

1. What is the process to agree which professional will initiate care planning and act as the “lead point of contact” for the service user?
2. Will initial plans be agreed with the service user in joint consultations or sequentially? Where and how will they be conducted?
3. What will be the process to agree the elements of the plans which should be available to professionals and potential authorised users beyond the immediate care teams, (A&E services, Ambulance Services, Social services, etc.) with the service user’s consent?
4. How will elements of the plan be updated following consultations in a way which is proportionate, to allow contact and progress notes to be maintained by the service conducting the consultation, whilst avoiding unnecessary work for partners in care if there is no significant change to the personalised care and support plan?
5. What are the implications for workload, logistics, and administration arising out of these decisions?

The answers to these questions and others will best be elicited through focused joint working, grounded in real, or at least realistic examples. This will entail process mapping, and co-design with a range of professionals, service users, and families. Resources from the toolkit and outputs from the Simulation element of this project will be valuable. Some organisations would adopt an approach such as a Rapid Process Improvement Workshop, planned over several weeks and conducted over a number of sequential days, to develop prototype ways of working that could be tested in the field.

“If someone’s been working for a period of time, in a form of therapy, for instance, where there’s an agreed plan for the locality when they may present in an emergency situation … then it’s really important for us to be able to see that that information and be able to act appropriately according to that because, you know, there isn’t and there shouldn’t be a stock response to that. These plans are designed to be individualised and personalised.  All services should be giving that personalised approach to care wherever possible. And a standard such as [PCSP standard] definitely moves us closer towards being able to do that. [Not acting on agreed plans] is a key finding in terms of emergency responses over the years where responses have been inappropriate.” – Mental Health Nurse

“Following a particular plan that’s been put into place will result in much better outcomes and prevent the sort of poor outcome which would otherwise be leading to an unplanned hospital admission.” – General Practitioner